Non-Legendary/Pseudo-Legendary Pokemon that SHOULD be Legendary!

[Professor Geoffrey]

Which non-legendary or pseudo-legendary (Metagross, Garchomp, Salamence, Dragonite, Tyrannitar) do you think should be legendary?

I believe the following should be legendary or have some other legendary status;

Lapras
Absol
Unown
Rotom
Spiritomb
Ninetails
Lucario


Mainly, out of these, I believe Unown should be legendary. The Unown are Pokemon of myth, and are more enigmatic and sacred than other legendary Pokemon. They are based off of the Latin alphabet, and are able to grant the wishes of whoever controls them. They can do more things than Jirachi can be asked for. They have their own dimension. They should be legendary!

What other Pokemon do you believe should be legendary?

[MaskedJackal]

Lucario's a legendary that can get laid. That's all.

[Metaphysical]

Unknown should be. It always seemed legendary to me. Kind of mysterious.

[Isaac8296]

I always thought that unown were legendary lol... but anyway... Ninetales really should've been legendary because I've always thought of it as a legendary until i found out it could evolve from Vulpix><"

[atucker22]

Arcanine was going to be legendary, but they scrapped the idea. Ninetails is a legend in PMD why not in the standard games. Every one you stated should be as well.

[Viva la Gofre]

None of the pokes you have listed deserve legendary status, because they are numberless and common. All of those pokes can either be bred or caught in the wild in limitless numbers. The primary trait all legendaries share is that they are one-of-a-kind, an aspect that none of your pokes have.

[coolmewkim22]

We have like twenty ledgies already, how many more do we need?

[TeirusuFX]

Originally Posted by A Requiem of Verities

Lapras
Absol
Unown
Rotom
Spiritomb
Ninetails
Lucario

When I saw that you made this thread, I knew I'd expect to see Lapras on that list :P

Unown is way too common to be legendary

I only have one Pokemon in mind: Ditto

If it can change into anything, including legendaries, wouldn't that make it the ultimate legendary?

♪テイルス♪
♫Teirusu♫

[Professor Geoffrey]

Originally Posted by Gofre

None of the pokes you have listed deserve legendary status, because they are numberless and common. All of those pokes can either be bred or caught in the wild in limitless numbers. The primary trait all legendaries share is that they are one-of-a-kind, an aspect that none of your pokes have.

Unown actually can't breed. As stated in the ninth movie, there were more than one Manaphy, and in the games, there were more than one Phione. There are more than one of each kind, I do believe. Like the time Charizard fought Anabel's Articuno. And when Brenden had those Regis. They were different from the ones in the movies. Therefore, only few legendary Pokemon are one-of-a-kind.

Originally Posted by TeirusuFX

When I saw that you made this thread, I knew I'd expect to see Lapras on that list :P

Lapras actually does deserve legendary status; it is one of very few Pokemon (mostly being legendary Pokemon) that can speak via telepathy. It is also exceedingly rare, much to the extent of the legendaries.

If it can change into anything, including legendaries, wouldn't that make it the ultimate legendary?

Basically Mew, the ancestor of all Pokemon. =]

[TeirusuFX]

Originally Posted by A Requiem of Verities

Unown actually can't breed. As stated in the ninth movie, there were more than one Manaphy, and in the games, there were more than one Phione. There are more than one of each kind, I do believe. Like the time Charizard fought Anabel's Articuno. And when Brenden had those Regis. They were different from the ones in the movies. Therefore, only few legendary Pokemon are one-of-a-kind.

Who said that all Pokemon can reproduce by breeding? There's a few I can think of that don't need to breed in order to reproduce, such as Muk

Lapras actually does deserve legendary status; it is one of very few Pokemon (mostly being legendary Pokemon) that can speak via telepathy. It is also exceedingly rare, much to the extent of the legendaries.

That was true only in 1st and 3rd gen

In the 2nd, it could be found every Friday

In the 4th, you can get it anytime

Basically Mew, the ancestor of all Pokemon. =]

Yes, I knew that too, but Ditto is way too common, it can copy anything, but yet it can be found in a specific area, and you can get many of them

It should be fair if you can only obtain one of those 'universal breeders'

♪テイルス♪
♫Teirusu♫

[Tory vs Meaty II]

Here is my argument, and this is not my thread: http://www.pokemonelite2000.com/foru...yl#post1478059

I also made a thread just like this here: http://www.pokemonelite2000.com/foru...te#post1756797. So don't let other users get off topic about predictions of new Pokemon, or your thread will get locked.

[Viva la Gofre]

Originally Posted by A Requiem of Verities

Unown actually can't breed.

Read my post again, I said if they can breed or be found in limitless quantities. Unown is categorized as the latter.

As stated in the ninth movie, there were more than one Manaphy, and in the games, there were more than one Phione.

The movies and the games are made by different people- gamefreak who are the creators and production companies who have bought the movie rights. As such inconsistencies rise, and the original creators always take precedence. As such manaphy is deemed legenday but I agree with that phione is not under my own criteria. Besides, their status is not what we are discussing, but rather the somewhat strange list you constructed.

There are more than one of each kind, I do believe. Like the time Charizard fought Anabel's Articuno. And when Brenden had those Regis. They were different from the ones in the movies. Therefore, only few legendary Pokemon are one-of-a-kind.

As I said before, games>>>anime. Besides, even by anime standards all definate legends are exceedingly rare while most of your list is commonplace in the pokemon world

Lapras actually does deserve legendary status; it is one of very few Pokemon (mostly being legendary Pokemon) that can speak via telepathy. It is also exceedingly rare, much to the extent of the legendaries.

Why lapras and not alakazam and other pokes with extreme intelligence? And don't pull the rarity card, as it can breed as well as the rest of them.



Basically Mew, the ancestor of all Pokemon. =]

So yeah, your pokes are still mundane.

[PokeGal]

IMO all pokes that were the main pokemon movies r/should be legend

[Ah Beng I the Pikabeng]

Originally Posted by Lord Lucario

Lucario's a legendary that can get laid. That's all.

It isn't. :|

Originally Posted by coolmewkim22

We have like twenty ledgies already, how many more do we need?

Yeah. More like there should be a thread for Legendary Pokemon that shouldn't be. :|

Originally Posted by TeirusuFX

When I saw that you made this thread, I knew I'd expect to see Lapras on that list :P

Unown is way too common to be legendary

I only have one Pokemon in mind: Ditto

If it can change into anything, including legendaries, wouldn't that make it the ultimate legendary?

♪テイルス♪
♫Teirusu♫

Ditto is also way too common.

Originally Posted by A Requiem of Verities

Unown actually can't breed. As stated in the ninth movie, there were more than one Manaphy, and in the games, there were more than one Phione. There are more than one of each kind, I do believe. Like the time Charizard fought Anabel's Articuno. And when Brenden had those Regis. They were different from the ones in the movies. Therefore, only few legendary Pokemon are one-of-a-kind.



Lapras actually does deserve legendary status; it is one of very few Pokemon (mostly being legendary Pokemon) that can speak via telepathy. It is also exceedingly rare, much to the extent of the legendaries.



Basically Mew, the ancestor of all Pokemon. =]

Even though there are multiples of some Legendary Pokemon, their numbers are still limited. Only those that you can easily get an unlimited number of without resetting the game are definitely confirmed to be Legendary Pokemon. And Pokemon such as Lapras and Unown fall under that category.

Also, just because a Pokemon can speak via telepathy doesn't mean that it must be Legendary Pokemon.

Originally Posted by TeirusuFX

Who said that all Pokemon can reproduce by breeding? There's a few I can think of that don't need to breed in order to reproduce, such as Muk

Um... the games' creators?

Originally Posted by TeirusuFX

That was true only in 1st and 3rd gen

In the 2nd, it could be found every Friday

In the 4th, you can get it anytime

So... strike Lapras out?

Yes, I knew that too, but Ditto is way too common, it can copy anything, but yet it can be found in a specific area, and you can get many of them

It should be fair if you can only obtain one of those 'universal breeders'

[/QUOTE]

Too late. >_>

What is definitely fair is for everyone to have an equal chance of getting them. Their fault if they don't take it.

Originally Posted by Tory vs Meaty II

Here is my argument, and this is not my thread: http://www.pokemonelite2000.com/foru...yl#post1478059

I also made a thread just like this here: http://www.pokemonelite2000.com/foru...te#post1756797. So don't let other users get off topic about predictions of new Pokemon, or your thread will get locked.

Originally Posted by Gofre

So yeah, your pokes are still mundane.

Originally Posted by Gofre

So yeah, your pokes are still mundane.

Actually, it's very much true that multiples exist for some Legendary Pokemon. For starters, 2 Mews can already be gotten in Generation I games.

[Gold Rush]

Arcanine should be legendary but I guess the makers decided agianst it :[