Battling Center Feedback: Now with new thought! =9

[Flygon Ruler]

Originally Posted by NinjaDuelist

Then it looks like the majority of us say one clan. Now, I wonder what lil_leprachaun is gonna say about this...

Also SuperT, I know that back in the old days it was fun to have only three clans, but that isn't part of our discussion. I'd recommend you staying on-topic, as I would hate to see you get in trouble because of off-topic discussion.

-ND

personally, this arguement is stupid. Who cares if people are in separate clans. Its really not all that fair to make people act like military men. Let them choose what they want to do. You can ahve your opinion, so listen to it, but that doesn't mean anyone else does. Let them do what they want. Forums are made for fun, not for people to stand inline and listen to bullies (yes, I'm talking to you mods and mini-mods!)

[Shinies]

Originally Posted by Flygon Ruler

personally, this arguement is stupid. Who cares if people are in separate clans. Its really not all that fair to make people act like military men. Let them choose what they want to do. You can ahve your opinion, so listen to it, but that doesn't mean anyone else does. Let them do what they want. Forums are made for fun, not for people to stand inline and listen to bullies (yes, I'm talking to you mods and mini-mods!)

That message coming from a guy in 3-4 clans....

Look, it should be one clan and one clan only because.....

1. When theres a war between clans your in you can pick the clan you like the most and get stuff on your opponents when your in that clan too.

2. It makes clans larger when they don't need to be, leading to more spam.

3.Makes the battling center look very unorganized.

[The Jr Trainer]

Originally Posted by Flygon Ruler

personally, this arguement is stupid. Who cares if people are in separate clans. Its really not all that fair to make people act like military men. Let them choose what they want to do. You can ahve your opinion, so listen to it, but that doesn't mean anyone else does. Let them do what they want. Forums are made for fun, not for people to stand inline and listen to bullies (yes, I'm talking to you mods and mini-mods!)

Well, we only care for the safety of those clans thereselves, we make them act that way so chaos doesn't arrive. If they don't listen to the "bullies" then they'll get "in trouble" (aka, if they don't listen to the mods/rules they'll get warned/infracted/banned). There are rules and they are there for a reason, if there weren't rules it would just be a monstrousity of chaos. So chaos or nice little school lunch lines? xD

See what I'm saying in a very confusing way? xD

~Jr

[Jack of Clovers]

I know you guys are upset. Oh, the Battling Center is dying, and it's not something I enjoy doing. But when I look around, the amount of spam and bad posts have been heavily minimized. The hardest part will be to keep it from coming back. Which is where you guys come in. I looked at Fullmetals recently rebuilt clan, and he did a great job responding to posts he didn't like, telling them why, and to not do it again. It really makes the clan look clean and organized.

With all that cut down, it'll be easy to work up activity again. Don't be afraid to post. I let small things slide; it's when it happens too much that I'll step in and do something.

Originally Posted by NinjaDuelist

Then it looks like the majority of us say one clan. Now, I wonder what lil_leprachaun is gonna say about this...

I pretty much already knew 'one clan' would pass. It has to if I'm going to continue upgrading and organizing. So let's start enforcing this today and let people know they need to pick one clan to stick with. This may create some chaos at first, so everyone try to help others as best you can.

Another questions I have: What's the point of being an Ally with another Clan?

~Jack~

[brettmeeink]

There's no point to ally really. I'm glad to see this is going to be enforced though. I think it will lead to more clan competition and an all around better atmosphere. Good job.

[The Jr Trainer]

Nope, no point, and when they do they usually combind together at one point or another. Making two clans into one. So it really isn't needed.

~Jr

[Professor Geoffrey]

Originally Posted by lil_leprachaun33

Another questions I have: What's the point of being an Ally with another Clan?

~Jack~

I have aboslutely no clue. I'm not an owner of a clan, so I'm not sure. Double wars? XD

.::GD::.

[Flygon Ruler]

Originally Posted by ShiniesRule1012

That message coming from a guy in 3-4 clans....

Look, it should be one clan and one clan only because.....

1. When theres a war between clans your in you can pick the clan you like the most and get stuff on your opponents when your in that clan too.

2. It makes clans larger when they don't need to be, leading to more spam.

3.Makes the battling center look very unorganized.

I'm in one clan you idiot! Don't post facts if you don't know that they're true.


I know there should be rules, but why make them so harsh? I understand that there are certain rules like no spamming, but when you make rules like this one it takes away the fun. If the clans don't want their members being in one clan, then they can run their clan accordingly.

I remember saying somewhere that they wished that there was only the three big clans ans no others. How says that the small clans won't grow big? That's kinda like saying a person is weak as a child and won't grow up to be someone like Gerge Washington.

[SHADOW SWORD]

Originally Posted by Flygon Ruler

I'm in one clan you idiot! Don't post facts if you don't know that they're true.


I know there should be rules, but why make them so harsh? I understand that there are certain rules like no spamming, but when you make rules like this one it takes away the fun. If the clans don't want their members being in one clan, then they can run their clan accordingly.

I remember saying somewhere that they wished that there was only the three big clans ans no others. How says that the small clans won't grow big? That's kinda like saying a person is weak as a child and won't grow up to be someone like Gerge Washington.

LL has already made his decision, lets stop the arguing and flaming. This thread was created to make the decision on the fact not to argue.

[NinjaDuelist]

Originally Posted by SHADOW SWORD

LL has already made his decision, lets stop the arguing and flaming. This thread was created to make the decision on the fact not to argue.

Agreed.

As for clans being allies, I haven't seen it used effectively in any way except for merging. Now, if clans were to ally up and take down another clan as sort of a handicap 2 on 1, then I could see it being effective. However, its never happened and I doubt it ever will.

My vote is that alliances are not to be allowed.

[Ace123456789]

An alliance just acknowledges that members of each clan can post in the other. I really don't understand why we would make that forbidden...

[NinjaDuelist]

Originally Posted by Ace123456789

An alliance just acknowledges that members of each clan can post in the other. I really don't understand why we would make that forbidden...

Does it serve any other purpose though? Not really. Like mentioned earlier, it would be cool if an alliance meant that they could take on a clan together, but no one has used that yet.

[Ace123456789]

Originally Posted by NinjaDuelist

Does it serve any other purpose though? Not really. Like mentioned earlier, it would be cool if an alliance meant that they could take on a clan together, but no one has used that yet.

Things don't have to serve a huge purpose to be allowed. I don't understand why this of all things should be prohibited...

[NinjaDuelist]

Originally Posted by Ace123456789

Things don't have to serve a huge purpose to be allowed. I don't understand why this of all things should be prohibited...

It does tend to generate spam, especially among the clans with a lot of newer members.

[Ace123456789]

Originally Posted by NinjaDuelist

It does tend to generate spam, especially among the clans with a lot of newer members.

If spam becomes a result, then punish the spammers. Don't take away the entire privilege.