Ash Vs. May, who really would've won?

[AshMistyMayfan]

They showed the finale (SPOILER IF YOU DON"T WANT TO KNOW)




















Ash and May finished in a draw. But seriously, who would've won that match, Sceptile vs. Blaziken? And why?

[-Starly-]

It would still be a tie.

Because the writers love to make Satoshi a DEM and have him perform extremely well in anything.

Plus, this is old news(at least for me).

[RouteMaster]

Part of me wants to say May because well it is Fire vs. Grass, but then remember this is the anime and that means diddly-squat. Ash is the new Champion of the Battle Frontier and an accomplished trainer. I'd say if the writer's hadn't tied it off nicely with a draw Ash would've won.

Mind you May is more familiar with the Contest format and the point system, she also had a good chance. Quite a hard one to call, but at a push probably Ash.

[Brendon]

Ash vs May I would think May would've won because of the type advantage she had.But it ended in a tie.

[-Starly-]

Since my first post is probably why they tied, I'll analyze the battle in this post.

Well, even though Bashamo had the type advantage towards Jukian, you have to remember that doesn't mean Bashamo would have won, no argument. There have been many times that a Pokémon has beaten another with a type disadvantage. Satoshi's Jukian would have still had a chance.

Also, you have to take into account that Wakashamo had just evolved into Bashamo. Of course Bashamon would have some difficulty with its new body while Jukian had enough time to get used to its body. This means that Jukian would be able outmaneuver Bashamo despite the type disadvantage. However, Satoshi isn't savvy about Contests, which is why he lost points for missing.

But since this is Haruka's finale, the writers wanted her to tie with Satoshi since they felt like she has matured enough to go head-to-head with Satoshi.

[Shadow Eevee]

You mean this is the season finale for battle frontier?

[-Starly-]

Originally Posted by Shadow Eevee

You mean this is the season finale for battle frontier?

No, it's the season finale for Johto.

[Pokeboy sarab]

Well may had the type advantage but ash had more experience so I go with the tie.

[umbreonandespeon]

May would have won,may knew the contest rules and stuff and she had the type advantage.

[Lonsie]

Ash is a better battler, no doubt, but it was May's last episode, so they couldn't have had her lose....

[Soul Dew]

Originally Posted by AshMistyMayfan

They showed the finale (SPOILER IF YOU DON"T WANT TO KNOW)




















Ash and May finished in a draw. But seriously, who would've won that match, Sceptile vs. Blaziken? And why?

Satoshi would win. Hands down