Re: What was YOUR game of the year?
Super Mario Galaxy 2 is my pick for game of the year, a fine refinement of the formula found in its predecessor. While it lacks the freedom that earlier Mario games possessed, you can't really complain about 30+ hours of tight control and innovative course platforming. Far and away the best platformer this generation. 8/10.
Honorable mentions of Sin & Punishment: Star Successor, Bayonetta, and Starcraft II.